Monday, October 13, 2014

Actions of the Watauga Board of Elections Ruled "Unconstitutional"

Here it is, the order by Judge Donald W. Stephens in the ASU student voting rights case from Watauga County, in toto (minus some preliminary stuff) and without comment:
...Respondent [State Board of Elections] Motion To Dismiss on the basis of seven enumerated grounds should be denied in its entirety and the matter should be remanded to Respondent [State Board of Elections] for adoption of an early voting plan for Watauga County consistent with this Order.
Upon review of the whole record, the Court makes the following conclusions:
1. Under the unique circumstances in this case, Respondent's early voting plan for Watauga County is subject to judicial review by the Wake County Superior Court under N.C. Gen. Stat. 163-22(a).
2. The Court has jurisdiction to exercise judicial review of this matter.
3. Upon review, questions of law are considered de novo.
4. The early voting plan Respondent adopted for Watauga County affects not only a substantial right, but a constitutional right of young voters in that county who are students at Appalachian State University (ASU).
5. The majority plan of the Watauga County Board of Elections on its face appears to have as a major purpose the elimination of an early voting site on the ASU campus. Based on this record, the court can conclude no other intent from that board's decision other than to discourage student voting. A decision based on that intent is a significant infringement of students' rights to vote and rises to the level of a constitutional violation of the right to vote.
6. The early voting plan submitted by the majority members of the Watauga County Board of Elections was arbitrary and capricious. All the credible evidence indicates that the sole purpose of that plan was to eliminate an early voting site on campus so as to discourage student voting and, as such, it is unconstitutional.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Defendant's Motion to Dismiss is DENIED in its entirety, that this matter is REMANDED to Respondent and that, upon remand, Respondent is directed to adopt an early voting plan for Watauga County for the 2014 November general election that includes at least one early voting site on the ASU campus.
This the 13th day of October, 2014.
Donald W. Stephens, President Superior Court Judge


KC said...


Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...

The irony is that something so plain to outsiders, the attempt to suppress the votes of the young by the local GOP heroes, is subject to continual debate right here in Boone. The Right can create a haze around the most insidious activities and manage to confuse about 47% of the population (or maybe 57%) even when the real purpose of their actions should be obvious.

def said...

Congrats and my commendations to all who put their time in to fight this!!